Widows: The Last Feminist Taboo Mineke Schipper Review

bookblast review mineke schipper

A long-standing project, Widows: The Last Feminist Taboo has taken a couple of decades to come to fruition. Mineke Schipper writes: ‘It is the first book to consider widows as a connected, global history. It uncovers the taboo that engulfs widowhood all over the world and across cultures, from Ancient Mesopotamia to Western Europe and everywhere in between. It looks at the customs, past and present, associated with widowhood. It asks questions that are both reflective and forward-thinking, such as: what does our treatment of widows tell us about society today? What does it suggest for our future?  And why are we so reluctant to talk about it?’

Both serious and humane, Widows is packed with all manner of odd facts, anecdotes and sayings that are witty and sharp with a grim undertow, gathered from around the world. ‘Never marry a widow unless her husband was hanged’, from England, made me simultaneously wince and laugh.

Widows has a special tone as it is by an historian who is herself a widow. Schipper found the contract for this book, signed by her publisher and agent, but as yet unsigned by her, when sorting through unopened post some months after the death of her husband.

‘A woman who buries her husband will not hesitate to bury another’ (France)

With an estimated 258 million widows in the world today, one in ten living in extreme poverty, widowhood remains what Schipper rightly terms ‘the last feminist taboo’. Historically overlooked by human rights campaigners and early women’s movements, this book clearly illustrates how the treatment of widows is a measure of how society treats women as a whole.

Schipper’s search takes in Egyptian papyri, Greek pottery, Aztec drawings, Confucian moral guides, Sumerian clay tablets, Chinese chastity arches, Victorian lockets, and the notes of colonial missionaries. She covers mourning, clothes, money and sex. The darker chapters cover witch trials, widow burning, inheritance law and child marriage.

The proverbs are the book’s greatest attribute, and the double standard they reveal is hard to miss. Widowers, it seems, cheer up fast and move on to fresh pastures. ‘Grief for a dead wife lasts to the door,’ say the French, Italians and Spanish. The Chechens do not bother with grieving at all, ‘Death of your wife; replacement in bed.’ A 4,000-year-old Sumerian tablet notes that ‘a widowed donkey makes a show of farting’. Men have been making jokes at widows’ expense since the invention of writing.

A widow who remarries is a hazard. A Polish proverb compares her to second-hand trousers: you never know who wore them before. A Danish one warns that ‘whoever gets the widow into his bed gets the dead man in his house.’ Schipper unearths a 1912 case from Georgia, USA, where a widow’s second husband was granted a divorce because her first husband’s ghost kept bothering them. She remarks that nobody ever seems to have been haunted by a dead wife.

Queen Victoria features of course. She wore black for forty years, set out hot shaving water for Albert every morning in the first year after his death, and was buried with a plaster cast of his hand. She was also buried, discreetly, with a lock of her Scottish ghillie John Brown’s hair. Her daughter Beatrice later censored the diaries with the help of some scissors.

“Grieving is hard work. Living doesn’t have to be”

‘The “bad” widow set out to continue living after her husband’s death. Bawdy extremes have been peddled by popular culture for comedic effect for centuries, such as Chaucer’s The Wife of Bath, Shakespeare’s Mistress Quickly, Aphra Behn’s The Widow Ranter and Hungarian composer Franz Lehár’s The Merry Widow. During the twentieth century, society’s fears and desires were projected on to widows in the form of fictional, sexualized figures like the Scottish Widow – exploited to sell life insurance – and the six female “merry murderess” suspects of the musical Chicago’s ‘”Cell Block Tango”.’

‘Jealousy gladly calls upon the help of witchcraft’ (Creole, Guadeloupe)

In 1605 the Dutch widow Mechteld ten Ham refused the respectable witch-weighing scales at Oudewater as nonsense. She chose the water ordeal instead, floated because air was trapped in her skirts, and was burned at the stake. Schipper also describes Indian widows confined to white saris and Chinese widows honoured with stone ‘chastity arches’ for never remarrying. Each chapter shows how ideas that start as proverbs end up as rules, and how those rules land on a woman’s body, her wardrobe and her bank balance.

What keeps the book from becoming an inventory of misery is its last chapter about those widows who refused to fade away. Instead, widowhood unexpectedly granted women unprecedented legal and economic independence. Christine de Pisan was widowed by the plague and went on to become one of medieval Europe’s few professional female writers. Tao Huabi was illiterate and widowed young; she started with a noodle stall and built Lao Gan Ma, the chilli-crisp empire that is probably sitting in your cupboard right now. These trailblazing women can inspire us today.

Why Read Widows? 

It shines a light on the ‘Hidden History’ of women: no one before has gathered so much history all in one volume about this subject. The proverbs are eminently quotable. Schipper exposes the roots of systemic misogyny across civilisations, and shows how society’s fear and mistrust of independent women has been codified into oral traditions and written laws through history. She shows that double standards surround grief, remarriage, and female autonomy and are anything but isolated cultural anomalies.  

‘A woman has no right to property, as she is property herself’ (Pat U. Okoye, Nigeria)

Many of the proverbs directly tie in with physical and economic control over women’s bodies, land theft, and physical violence. Patriarchal societies attempt to suppress female sexuality through practices such as forced wearing of mourning weeds and property-grabbing.  

While reading Widows, two very different modern misogynistic contexts came to mind concerning male control, the policing of female appearance, and the systemic devaluation of women.

The first is Afghanistan, one of the most extreme examples of patriarchal control harshly applied today. Women are systematically erased from public life as they are stripped of their right to work, banned from receiving an education, subjected to strictly enforced dress codes, and a recent law bans women from raising their voice in public.

The second, operating through soft power, is clear to see in Western right-wing conservative circles such as the MAGA movement in the US. The extreme plastic surgery, uniform styling, and rigid aesthetic standards among prominent women married to the men currently in power reflects an obsession with perpetual youth and pristine beauty. Their uber-curated Barbie doll appearance is less about individual style and more about conforming to a rigid masculine ideal of femininity. Ultimately those women who adapt to male expectations become enforcers of the very norms that commodify them.

Lavish illustrations reinforce the central themes of Widows. The extensive bibliography encompassing a remarkably wide range of sources across centuries and disciplines, and the detailed index, make Widows a meticulously crafted work that is as accessible to general readers as it is invaluable to historians.

BUY Widows

Buying books using the ‘BUY’ links helps support independent bookshops and our work as a CIC. The copyright to all the content of this site is held by the individual authors and creators. All rights reserved. Enquiries: please use the contact form.

About Georgia de Chamberet 446 Articles
Bilingual editor, rewriter, anthologist, French-to-English translator. Has written for 3am magazine, words without borders, The Independent, The Lady, Banipal, Prospect Magazine, Times Literary Supplement. Currently writes for The BookBlast Diary. Founder (1997) of London-based writing agency BookBlast.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.